Eric Caldwell

SPE-169633-MS A Selection Methodology for 13Cr-Type Alloy Oil Country Tubular Goods

Significant interest exists in the deployment of 13Cr martensitic stainless steels in offshore oil and gas projects. Several grades of 13Cr exist, with the seemingly negligible variations between their chemistries and fabrication processes. The different grades perform dramatically differently, especially regarding cracking resistance in sour or chloride-containing environments. Determination of the proper 13Cr grade for sour service involves the investigation of domain diagrams, and often requires further fitness-for-service testing. However, the validity of each domain diagram for only one chloride concentration or content greatly limits their practicality for selecting 13Cr, thus impeding the ability to determining if fitness-for-service testing should be performed and its potential outcome. 

SPE 147205 - Materials Selection: A Systems Engineering Approach

2011 Abstract, Eric Caldwell, Karthik Annadorai, Grant Gibson, Lee Jordan

Subsea and topsides materials selection is becoming a vital part in the development and long term sustainability of deepwater oil and gas production facilities. Increasing challenges associated with capital and operating cost constraints, schedule compression, remote locations, and the need to deploy materials ever closer to their known limits makes fit for purpose materials selection a complex and difficult issue that crosses many different discipline boundaries. Materials selection is primarily governed by corrosion engineering principles and applied chemical inhibition practices, and then by project specifics. However, there are two different practices that are generally followed that dictate how materials are ultimately selected. The first is by a standard materials selection process using guidance such as that provided in NORSOK M-001, and the second is by using a more informal system with limited guidance that involves individually selecting materials for a specific project.

 In actuality, the materials selection process is a combination of both. The selection process to identify which materials are considered appropriate is routine and straightforward and is dictated by various corrosion parameters and associated risks. Often this high-level assessment does not appropriately address project specifics, so causing the final material selections to be substantially different from those initially proposed.

One of the specific items that often drives this change in materials selection philosophy is the use of chemical inhibitors for corrosion inhibition and the perceived feasibility and level of risk associated with this. Use of a systems engineering approach to material selection can be used beneficially as a process that accelerates the determination and initial optimization of the materials, and the selection of chemicals and their injection locations, and associated monitoring methods and locations in a given topsides, subsea or water injection system design.

Source: SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, 30 October-2 November 2011, Denver, Colorado, USA

Copyright 2011. Society of Petroleum Engineers

Read More 

NACE 11099 - Further Analysis On M13Cr-110 NACE TM0177 Method A Test Acceptability Prediction

2011 Abstract, Eric Caldwell, Grant Gibson, Lee Jordan

Martensitic stainless steels continue to be one of the most widely used corrosion resistant alloys in oil and gas developments. Determining if a martensitic stainless steel is acceptable in an unproven environment requires testing to confirm, but predicting the outcome of a given test environment is often initially based on personal experience rather than a qualitative and quantitative assessment. An empirical method for improving the predictability of NACE TM0177 Method A Tensile tests on modified 13Cr 110ksi grade martensitic stainless steels based on an H2S/Chloride/pH function has previously been developed based on published data in order to address this uncertainty. The environments considered by this function are only limited by the capabilities of the NACE TM0177 Method A test, and provide a method for rapidly estimating if a M13Cr 110ksi grade should pass or fail in multiple different environments. As a follow-on to the development of this empirical method, data points from new tests were used to check the general predictability of the H2S/Chloride/pH function. The general function was modified due to the addition of the new data, and subsequently checked again against a separate set of data. The nature and implications of these findings are discussed and conclusions drawn regarding the performance and value of the methodology for the evaluation of future materials applications.

Source: CORROSION 2011, March 13 - 17, 2011 , Houston, Texas

Copyright 2011. NACE International

Read More